The word "plankton" literally means "wanderer", and these floating wanderers of the ocean have a strange and alien beauty that has fascinated generations of biologists.
The Plankton Chronicles project uses modern microscopy and videography to make this world accessible to the average armchair explorer. They've produced a series of videos highlighting different planktonic organisms, using a technique called dark field optics, where objects are made visible by the light that they scatter, appearing light against a dark background.
The project is a collaboration between the Tara Oceans Expedition and the Oceanographical Observatory at Villefranche-sur-Mer.
One of the episodes, on planktonic protists (of course!), is embedded below:
I came by the site by way of this TED Talk by Tierney Thys:
Showing posts with label communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label communication. Show all posts
Monday, April 09, 2012
Plankton Chronicles
Labels:
communication,
invertebrates,
Marine,
protists,
video
Wednesday, December 28, 2011
How the 'brinicle' was filmed
If you haven't seen this video by now, you should watch it!
As sea ice freezes in the Antarctic, it leaves behind a concentrated brine which is trapped in channels within the ice. When this cold, dense brine, which is colder than the freezing point of water, seeps to the underside of the ice layer and sinks into the water beneath, it forms a sheath of frozen water around it, which eventually extends to the sea floor as a 'brinicle'.
For the BBC Nature series Frozen Planet, these brinicles were filmed for the very first time. The film's producer, Kathryn Jeffs, said that when she was preparing to film them, she couldn't find any information about them, even on the Internet.
Now, this video is among the most popular nature video clips online.
Jeff describes the technically demanding and physically difficult process of filming under thick ice in 2ºC water. As she put it, they were tremendously satisfied when they
As sea ice freezes in the Antarctic, it leaves behind a concentrated brine which is trapped in channels within the ice. When this cold, dense brine, which is colder than the freezing point of water, seeps to the underside of the ice layer and sinks into the water beneath, it forms a sheath of frozen water around it, which eventually extends to the sea floor as a 'brinicle'.
For the BBC Nature series Frozen Planet, these brinicles were filmed for the very first time. The film's producer, Kathryn Jeffs, said that when she was preparing to film them, she couldn't find any information about them, even on the Internet.
Now, this video is among the most popular nature video clips online.
Jeff describes the technically demanding and physically difficult process of filming under thick ice in 2ºC water. As she put it, they were tremendously satisfied when they
... knew [they] had captured, for the first time ever, the creation of a rather sinister wonder of nature.
Thursday, October 06, 2011
Afterword on "arsenic-life" affair
Popular Science magazine has recently published a profile by Tom Clynes on the scientist in the middle of the "arsenic life" controversy, Felisa Wolfe-Simon (see previous Biology Refugia post). This comes after the Science finally published her paper in its 3 June 2011 print issue, along with a selection of responses from her critics (see the editor's note for links).
The magazine feature is sympathetic to her, and notes how much of the initial criticism started by criticizing the science then moved into questioning the scientists' motivations. Many accusations were made at the time, including that they were motivated by fame as a result doing "bad science". But Science didn't publish her paper without peer-review. In fact, additional evidence was gathered as a result of peer review. Were the results inadequate for the claims which were made in the media ("new form of life", "proof that extraterrestrial life is possible", etc.)? Yes, certainly.
My opinion is that this was a "perfect storm" caused by the confluence of mass media and science. Without making any assumptions about anyone's motivations, Wolfe-Simon's team or their critics, we can say that (i) the hyped-up press conference organized by NASA was a mistake, and the oversimplified media kit only led to a proliferation of misinformed headlines, (ii) the quick criticisms by scientists posted to their blogs and websites appeared much faster than any research team could possibly respond to carefully, (iii) the media attention on Wolfe-Simon made it difficult to respond to technical criticisms and also increased their defensive posture (reading the Pop Sci article, I'm struck by how overwhelming it must have been for her) – simply finding the time to do it would have been difficult. I quote Clynes's article:
The magazine feature is sympathetic to her, and notes how much of the initial criticism started by criticizing the science then moved into questioning the scientists' motivations. Many accusations were made at the time, including that they were motivated by fame as a result doing "bad science". But Science didn't publish her paper without peer-review. In fact, additional evidence was gathered as a result of peer review. Were the results inadequate for the claims which were made in the media ("new form of life", "proof that extraterrestrial life is possible", etc.)? Yes, certainly.
My opinion is that this was a "perfect storm" caused by the confluence of mass media and science. Without making any assumptions about anyone's motivations, Wolfe-Simon's team or their critics, we can say that (i) the hyped-up press conference organized by NASA was a mistake, and the oversimplified media kit only led to a proliferation of misinformed headlines, (ii) the quick criticisms by scientists posted to their blogs and websites appeared much faster than any research team could possibly respond to carefully, (iii) the media attention on Wolfe-Simon made it difficult to respond to technical criticisms and also increased their defensive posture (reading the Pop Sci article, I'm struck by how overwhelming it must have been for her) – simply finding the time to do it would have been difficult. I quote Clynes's article:
I find it hard not to feel sympathy for her. In a matter of weeks she was catapulted to fame, then singled out and assaulted with professional and personal criticism, some of which resulted from missteps beyond her control. Wolfe-Simon is an early-career researcher in a field dominated by older men. Few scientists, no matter how established, would have the skills to navigate the situation that she found herself in. What made the level of criticism so extraordinary is that the paper, in itself, is not so flawed that it should not have been published. The argument was compelling, the conclusions were measured, the data was thorough, and the paper made it through the same peer-review process as other articles in Science.
Some who initially blasted Wolfe-Simon have since changed their mind. Blogger Alan Townsend, who directs the environmental studies program at the University of Colorado, says he was guilty of rash judgment, and that his preliminary opinions—expressed in writing and conversations with his colleagues—contributed to a response from the scientific community that was “often unprofessional, and at times became downright shameful.” He says, “Absent major ethical violations, no junior scientist full of passion for an idea deserves crucifixion for a professional failure or two. If a paper is flawed, it should be dismissed. The scientist should not.”Learning to deal with the media is not typically part of a scientist's education. After all, most could only wish they were so lucky. If the need should arise at all, it's probably handled by PR departments of their institutions or employers, or from the agencies that fund them, like NASA in this case. Perhaps it's time for scientists to come together and figure out what a code of conduct for publicizing their work should be like. For example, is it a conflict of interest to write a newspaper column that trumpets your own work while raising criticism of your competitors, especially if this is unpublished research? How far should we go in "jazzing up" the science in order to sell it to the public? Some degree of spin and oversimplification is unavoidable, but a technical audience would know where to look when reading a scientific paper to judge for themselves whether a specific claim is justifiable (typically buried somewhere in the Materials and Methods). Should we always be cautious and measured in our pronouncements? What if the issue is something politically-charged like climate change, where climate change "deniers" seize upon caution and use it as supposed evidence of falsehood? Difficult questions for difficult times, and scientists should take the lead in trying to figure them out.
Saturday, October 01, 2011
Planet Earths' debt ceiling
You may have not noticed it amid all the news on the economy, but on Tuesday we've gone into ecological debt for the year. 27 September was this year's Earth Overshoot Day (via Discover), the day when human consumption and waste emission for the year has exceeded the Earth's annual productivity and ability to absorb waste. The organization responsible for this announcement is the NGO Global Footprint Network, which seeks to raise awareness of environmental sustainability. They've issued a media packet explaining the concept here (pdf). The idea was originally mooted by the UK-based new economics foundation (they do their name in lowercase) in the 1980s as Ecological Debt Day.
It sounds like a straightforward calculation of income minus expenditure, but the reality of course is quite complicated. Most of the parameters, such as crop productivity and human greenhouse gas emissions, have to be estimated, so the date is not an exact one. Despite the uncertainties, the calculated date is actually be on the more generous (to humans) end of the scale.
What's scarier is that the date has been moving forward every year: from sometime in early November in 2001, to late September now, about 3 days a year. Even scarier, this ignores the cumulative effect of previous times when we've gone into debt. This crisis mirrors the financial one: in some heavily indebted countries, politicians are happy to report when they've simply slowed down the rate of debt increase.
This is a good way of getting people's attention, because of all the headlines that the poor economy has been grabbing lately. Even non-economists, like myself, have become acquainted with concepts like debt ceilings, defaults, and bailouts (though what a "tranche" is still remains opaque to me). Environmentalists and sustainability scientists are also working on figuring out how to put an economic price on ecosystems and the environment, to make the importance of preserving the environment more "real" to those who think in dollars and cents, such as policymakers and industry. Examples include factoring in the cost of ecosystem services into environmental impact assessments, or selling carbon credits, or swapping habitat protection for debt forgiveness. All of these schemes have their critics, but I like to think of them as experiments in progress, as people try to figure out what's a workable way to account for the environmental impact of our economic decisions.
| From Global Footprint Network website |
It sounds like a straightforward calculation of income minus expenditure, but the reality of course is quite complicated. Most of the parameters, such as crop productivity and human greenhouse gas emissions, have to be estimated, so the date is not an exact one. Despite the uncertainties, the calculated date is actually be on the more generous (to humans) end of the scale.
What's scarier is that the date has been moving forward every year: from sometime in early November in 2001, to late September now, about 3 days a year. Even scarier, this ignores the cumulative effect of previous times when we've gone into debt. This crisis mirrors the financial one: in some heavily indebted countries, politicians are happy to report when they've simply slowed down the rate of debt increase.
This is a good way of getting people's attention, because of all the headlines that the poor economy has been grabbing lately. Even non-economists, like myself, have become acquainted with concepts like debt ceilings, defaults, and bailouts (though what a "tranche" is still remains opaque to me). Environmentalists and sustainability scientists are also working on figuring out how to put an economic price on ecosystems and the environment, to make the importance of preserving the environment more "real" to those who think in dollars and cents, such as policymakers and industry. Examples include factoring in the cost of ecosystem services into environmental impact assessments, or selling carbon credits, or swapping habitat protection for debt forgiveness. All of these schemes have their critics, but I like to think of them as experiments in progress, as people try to figure out what's a workable way to account for the environmental impact of our economic decisions.
Labels:
climate,
communication,
environment,
humans,
pollution
Tuesday, August 02, 2011
End of a botanical tradition
Botanical Latin is a curious creature, with a grammar and vocabulary very different from classical or medieval Latin. It dates back to the traditional use of Latin in scientific and scholarly works as the common language of learning in multi-lingual Europe. In modern times, it has been restricted to the formal description, called a 'diagnosis', of a newly-published plant species.
As Latin grew less important to general education, however, botanists have had to seek help from other quarters in writing these diagnoses, but because of the independent evolution of botanical Latin for its special purposes:
New editions of the Code are voted upon at meetings of the International Botanical Congress, and at the latest meeting in Melbourne, Australia, this tradition of botanical Latin may have met its demise (Nature news and editorial). Attendees have voted for several amendments to the code (full list of proposals here), including dropping the requirement for botanical Latin in new descriptions, and allowing the publication of new species names in electronic journals. The full congress will have to ratify these amendments before they become permanent.
The demise of botanical Latin might have been just a matter of time, but the issue of electronic publication is a relatively new one. Electronic-only journals have been proliferating, but for taxonomy, which is concerned with permanence and record-keeping rather than rapid communication of information, they have distinct disadvantages. There is no guarantee that a server crash or corrupted computer file may not wipe out a species description forever, resulting in a book-keeping nightmare when species names have to be revised or updated. The zoological Code, for example, still requires that a number of hard paper copies be sent to libraries around the world as an insurance against that possibility. This is what the Raffles Bulletin of Zoology, which is published in Singapore as an online journal, does to fulfill the requirements of the code.
So does this mean that William T Stearn's classic reference book, Botanical Latin, will become obsolete immediately? Not necessarily. A big fraction of the historical botanical literature, especially the earliest works from the time of Linnaeus onwards, are written exclusively in Latin and no translations exist for them. We also owe much of our technical nomenclature to Latin and Greek. Botanical Latin may be newly dead, but it still lives on.
As Latin grew less important to general education, however, botanists have had to seek help from other quarters in writing these diagnoses, but because of the independent evolution of botanical Latin for its special purposes:
... when a botanical author thanks a professor of classics for providing a Latin description, this is usually in bad or at any rate unconventional botanical Latin... (W.T. Stearn, Botanical Latin, viii.)The use of Latin was codified in the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature - a set of rules for keeping the profusion of scientific names in order. It was preserved for both tradition's sake and also because taxonomists have usually argued that a common language is needed to keep communication possible amidst a profusion of vernacular languages. The parallel Zoological Code, however, did away with Latin descriptions a long time ago.
New editions of the Code are voted upon at meetings of the International Botanical Congress, and at the latest meeting in Melbourne, Australia, this tradition of botanical Latin may have met its demise (Nature news and editorial). Attendees have voted for several amendments to the code (full list of proposals here), including dropping the requirement for botanical Latin in new descriptions, and allowing the publication of new species names in electronic journals. The full congress will have to ratify these amendments before they become permanent.
The demise of botanical Latin might have been just a matter of time, but the issue of electronic publication is a relatively new one. Electronic-only journals have been proliferating, but for taxonomy, which is concerned with permanence and record-keeping rather than rapid communication of information, they have distinct disadvantages. There is no guarantee that a server crash or corrupted computer file may not wipe out a species description forever, resulting in a book-keeping nightmare when species names have to be revised or updated. The zoological Code, for example, still requires that a number of hard paper copies be sent to libraries around the world as an insurance against that possibility. This is what the Raffles Bulletin of Zoology, which is published in Singapore as an online journal, does to fulfill the requirements of the code.
So does this mean that William T Stearn's classic reference book, Botanical Latin, will become obsolete immediately? Not necessarily. A big fraction of the historical botanical literature, especially the earliest works from the time of Linnaeus onwards, are written exclusively in Latin and no translations exist for them. We also owe much of our technical nomenclature to Latin and Greek. Botanical Latin may be newly dead, but it still lives on.
Thursday, December 30, 2010
Singapore Mangroves "Smelly, Dirty"?
Ron Yeo, who writes the nature blog The Tide Chaser, has written a paean to Singapore's under-appreciated mangrove swamps for The Online Citizen.
The mangrove habitat is a staple for school field trips and biodiversity classes, but being 'in the choir' (the one that is being preached to, in the idiom), I and maybe many of this blog's readers tend to forget that:
So I might add to what Yeo's suggests: if you care about nature in Singapore and spend time in our parks and forests, bring a camera and with just a little bit of luck you'll have some pretty pictures of flowers or animals to share online. Then you can answer the question "Singapore forests got anything to see, meh?", and show that appreciating nature is as much about how closely you look, as where you go. In this digitally-driven age, seeing it first on the computer screen might just be the 'hook' to bring people outdoors to see with their own eyes.
The mangrove habitat is a staple for school field trips and biodiversity classes, but being 'in the choir' (the one that is being preached to, in the idiom), I and maybe many of this blog's readers tend to forget that:
Dark, smelly, dirty, muddy, scary, mosquito infested, illegal immigrant infested… Ask the usual Singaporeans what they think of our mangroves, and these are some of the common responses. In fact, I even had a friend telling me that he did not like going to mangroves because he was afraid of snakes dropping down from the trees.Yeo suggests that we should get people to break from these preconceived notions and actually go to see it for themselves. But let's be honest, mangroves do smell funky, and even if you do manage to get your city slicker friends or family to take a trip down to see what all the fuss is about, they might still complain about the heat and remember mostly the mosquitoes, especially if your stories aren't captivating enough or the otters are a no-show. Singaporeans can be a hard lot to please, right?
So I might add to what Yeo's suggests: if you care about nature in Singapore and spend time in our parks and forests, bring a camera and with just a little bit of luck you'll have some pretty pictures of flowers or animals to share online. Then you can answer the question "Singapore forests got anything to see, meh?", and show that appreciating nature is as much about how closely you look, as where you go. In this digitally-driven age, seeing it first on the computer screen might just be the 'hook' to bring people outdoors to see with their own eyes.
Sunday, December 19, 2010
Arsenic claim petering out
So it seems like the claim for bacteria using arsenic in their biomolecules was never strong to begin with. During the original press conference, the token skeptic was a chemist, and most of the criticism comes from those who are convinced that the chemistry of the matter is quite unlikely. The bacteria are not 'thriving' on arsenic, by any means, but merely tolerating it.
The original paper claimed that only a fraction of the phosphorus was being replaced by arsenic, but it seems likely that as other labs try to replicate their results, this value will be revised downwards.
Red faces all around - including this one! - for feeding the hype, and many people are pointing to NASA's infamous 'life on Mars' claim as prior precedent for the dangers of mixing science and the media.
Read more:
The authors released a technical statement responding to criticism on methods (pdf original, html version on USA Today)
A good newsy summary from the Philadelphia Inquirer.
Ed Yong at Discover Magazine summarizes the timeline and reflects on the practice of science journalism.
The original paper claimed that only a fraction of the phosphorus was being replaced by arsenic, but it seems likely that as other labs try to replicate their results, this value will be revised downwards.
Red faces all around - including this one! - for feeding the hype, and many people are pointing to NASA's infamous 'life on Mars' claim as prior precedent for the dangers of mixing science and the media.
Read more:
The authors released a technical statement responding to criticism on methods (pdf original, html version on USA Today)
A good newsy summary from the Philadelphia Inquirer.
Ed Yong at Discover Magazine summarizes the timeline and reflects on the practice of science journalism.
Saturday, December 18, 2010
Highlights from BBC's Decade of Discovery
A new program, "Decade of Discovery", by the BBC showcases the 'greatest hits' from the past 10 years of natural history exploration, including the first live images of the barreleye fish (which can only look up and has a transparent dome over its head), the world's longest stick-insect, and more. Some video clips are available on the BBC's YouTube channel or from the TV program's webpage linked above, and the Guardian newspaper has a picture gallery of highlights if you're in a hurry.
Thursday, December 09, 2010
"Arsenic-life" under fire?
Slate magazine reports on criticism of the recently-released report on bacteria that use arsenic in place of phosphorus. Much of the concern arises from the possibility that the arsenic detected in these biomolecules were not endogenous but instead contaminants. Some scientists are also dissatisfied with how NASA was performing "science by press release", pumping up the publicity machine ahead of the paper's publication.
It remains to be seen how the team that produced this paper will respond; they are willing to give cultures of the strain to any researcher who wants to investigate their claims, and detailed criticisms are presently being prepared for publication.
In all likelihood, though, the mass media will not be as interested in probably prolonged back-and-forth that will ensue, the news cycle isn't quite patient enough for such sustained coverage. This of course is a pity because it biases how the public views science: as a string of spectacular discoveries, but without any of the routine counter-checking that goes on afterward.
It remains to be seen how the team that produced this paper will respond; they are willing to give cultures of the strain to any researcher who wants to investigate their claims, and detailed criticisms are presently being prepared for publication.
In all likelihood, though, the mass media will not be as interested in probably prolonged back-and-forth that will ensue, the news cycle isn't quite patient enough for such sustained coverage. This of course is a pity because it biases how the public views science: as a string of spectacular discoveries, but without any of the routine counter-checking that goes on afterward.
Monday, November 29, 2010
Book Review: The Art Instinct
Book reviewed -- Denis Dutton. The Art Instinct. New York: Bloomsbury Press. 2009.
Modern humans have a profound fascination with our Pleistocene past, in part because many of us, disillusioned by technology and modernity, find something more authentic and natural in the ways of hunter-gatherers. A recent post by fellow Refugee, Alvin, highlights research suggesting that barefoot running may be better for our bodies. For some people, the 'Paleolithic Diet' is becoming fashionable, while even literary theorists are looking to Darwin and the hunter-gatherer psyche to explain the ins and outs of literature. Can other human endeavors, like art and music, be explained by our evolutionary past in the same way?
Modern humans have a profound fascination with our Pleistocene past, in part because many of us, disillusioned by technology and modernity, find something more authentic and natural in the ways of hunter-gatherers. A recent post by fellow Refugee, Alvin, highlights research suggesting that barefoot running may be better for our bodies. For some people, the 'Paleolithic Diet' is becoming fashionable, while even literary theorists are looking to Darwin and the hunter-gatherer psyche to explain the ins and outs of literature. Can other human endeavors, like art and music, be explained by our evolutionary past in the same way?
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
Sherman's Lagoon and the Census of Marine Life
The Census of Marine Life (CoML) is an international project to account for the world's marine biodiversity. Launched in 2000, it has now completed a decade of research, and is celebrating this milestone with a conference in London.
The results have been more than just scientific publications and pretty coffee table books. Artwork inspired by the Census includes a storyline in Jim Toomey's comic strip Sherman's Lagoon (scroll down this page to see), which follows the foibles of a (not very bright) Great White shark and his friends. Toomey has given a TED talk where he talks about his love of the ocean and marine life, including his stand against shark finning.
The results have been more than just scientific publications and pretty coffee table books. Artwork inspired by the Census includes a storyline in Jim Toomey's comic strip Sherman's Lagoon (scroll down this page to see), which follows the foibles of a (not very bright) Great White shark and his friends. Toomey has given a TED talk where he talks about his love of the ocean and marine life, including his stand against shark finning.
Saturday, October 09, 2010
Like maps? Help map IUCN Red List data
| Distribution of the Spanish Ibex, drawn from IUCN data. (Source: By Nrg800 [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], from Wikimedia Commons) |
If you've always wanted to do something with GIS (geographic information systems) but needed data to make pretty maps with, why not help draw species distribution maps for Wikimedia Commons? The International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has partnered with Wikimedia to put the species distribution data from its Red List of threatened and endangered species in the public domain. Wikimedia is looking for volunteers to map this data onto a world map background, to produce distribution maps for species with available data (about 25 000 of them). An example is shown above.
Sunday, October 03, 2010
Advice for Scientists-turned-Wikipedians
| The most influential information resource in the world? |
Biologists, especially those involved in biodiversity, are in a great position to contribute, but how do we start? Here are ten simple rules from scientists at Cambridge and the Sanger Institute on what to do and what to avoid.
They observe that the anonymity of the Internet makes it possible for a nonexpert Wikipedian with editorial status to reject your well-crafted, expert opinion on a subject for a variety of reasons. The inability to argue from academic authority on Wikipedia is, in my opinion, a good thing for science writing - it promotes clarity and simplicity in the communication of scientific ideas and information, which feeds back into how we think and write about science both for scientists and the public.
For educators, having students write mock-up Wikipedia entries, or criticize (carefully chosen) existing entries on a given subject may be very useful in demonstrating the both the potential and limitation of Wikipedia as an information resource. The act of writing for a general audience will also certainly help consolidate one's own knowledge.
Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Sea grape symbionts - parasites turned mutualists
The research project that I'm working on involves a symbiotic protist found in sea grapes, which are a family of sea squirts, or ascidians - sessile, filter feeding invertebrates which turn out to be close relatives of vertebrates (they're also chordates). Carl Zimmer, a science writer at the NY Times and other publications, has just blogged about a paper just published by one of my advisers, Mary Beth Saffo, and collaborators. The paper has been a long time in the works, so it's gratifying to see that it's gotten some publicity already. It's interesting how these things work, though - he found out about it because he was visiting the same marine biology station where she was doing some field work. There's plenty of serendipity in science communication, on top of the inherent general interest of the work itself.
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Zombie ants in news, and musings on science reporting...
Markings on fossil leaves appear to be the 'death grip' of ants infected by the so-called zombie fungus, Ophiocordyceps. The fungus causes the infected ants to move to a position on nearby vegetation and die immobilized there, such that the sprouting fruiting body of the fungus will more efficiently spread its spores over yet more ants. This grip leaves distinctive markings on the leaves, which were recognized by a group led by David Hughes (disclosure: I have met David and heard him talk about his work).
Having this fossil evidence allows us to be able to give a minimum age for the history of this fungal life-style. Despite advances in the study of molecular evolution, fossil evidence is still the most direct way to pin a date on events in the history of life. Earlier hopes that the rate of changes in nucleotide or amino-acid sequences could provide an objective 'molecular clock' (first proposed in the 1960s by Emile Zuckerkandl and Linus Pauling - yes, that Linus Pauling) turned out to be premature, because rates of molecular evolution are not generally uniform across species and even in single lineages over time, and therefore need to be calibrated, typically against the fossil record.
---
On the topic of science reporting: The Guardian newspaper article linked above is better than most newspaper science reporting, however, it still illustrates a few sticky points that nag at me when I read about science in the news.
Chief among these is the lack of citations. That is disconcerting, especially to someone in an academic setting where proper attribution is always emphasized. Science reporters are quite uneven in how they cite things: some simply omit any mention of where the research they describe is going to be published (or has been published), some state the journal name and leave it at that, and only in a few cases is a full citation (or in this article: a link to a PubMed record) given. Here, however, note that the PubMed link is to an earlier paper on a related topic, but not about the issue being directly reported. The article says that the scientific report is published in Biology Letters, but a quick search in the journal's website turned up no hits. Hence I can only conclude that it's yet to be published, and the reporter was privy to a prepublication preview.
Unfortunately, this affects blogging, too. I'm happy to highlight interesting papers and newspaper reports on biology, but without having seen the original paper, if new research is being presented, it is hard to assess the quality and reliability of the work, and whether it really is worth being blogged about. Worse yet, the reporter may have distorted the actual conclusions, or misrepresented the facts, ... the list goes on.
So the next time you see a newspaper article reporting new research, do keep an eye out - drop a comment here if you see something noteworthy that shows how caution is necessary.
Having this fossil evidence allows us to be able to give a minimum age for the history of this fungal life-style. Despite advances in the study of molecular evolution, fossil evidence is still the most direct way to pin a date on events in the history of life. Earlier hopes that the rate of changes in nucleotide or amino-acid sequences could provide an objective 'molecular clock' (first proposed in the 1960s by Emile Zuckerkandl and Linus Pauling - yes, that Linus Pauling) turned out to be premature, because rates of molecular evolution are not generally uniform across species and even in single lineages over time, and therefore need to be calibrated, typically against the fossil record.
---
On the topic of science reporting: The Guardian newspaper article linked above is better than most newspaper science reporting, however, it still illustrates a few sticky points that nag at me when I read about science in the news.
Chief among these is the lack of citations. That is disconcerting, especially to someone in an academic setting where proper attribution is always emphasized. Science reporters are quite uneven in how they cite things: some simply omit any mention of where the research they describe is going to be published (or has been published), some state the journal name and leave it at that, and only in a few cases is a full citation (or in this article: a link to a PubMed record) given. Here, however, note that the PubMed link is to an earlier paper on a related topic, but not about the issue being directly reported. The article says that the scientific report is published in Biology Letters, but a quick search in the journal's website turned up no hits. Hence I can only conclude that it's yet to be published, and the reporter was privy to a prepublication preview.
Unfortunately, this affects blogging, too. I'm happy to highlight interesting papers and newspaper reports on biology, but without having seen the original paper, if new research is being presented, it is hard to assess the quality and reliability of the work, and whether it really is worth being blogged about. Worse yet, the reporter may have distorted the actual conclusions, or misrepresented the facts, ... the list goes on.
So the next time you see a newspaper article reporting new research, do keep an eye out - drop a comment here if you see something noteworthy that shows how caution is necessary.
Labels:
communication,
evolution,
fossils,
fungi,
insects,
interactions,
symbiosis
Friday, June 04, 2010
Many Pacific Islands Not Shrinking Despite Sea-level Change
One of the feared consequences of climate change is that low-lying islands in Oceania and elsewhere will become submerged by rising sea levels. A new study to be published in Global and Planetary Change by researchers from the South Pacific Applied Geoscience Commission and the University of Auckland looked at the land area of 27 atoll islands in the Pacific, and found that despite the sea level rising at an average rate of 2 mm per year over the period for which data was available, most of the islands either stayed the same size or grew, and only four actually shrank.
Land area change was small compared to other 'gross changes':
The composition of the islands is responsible for their dynamism and ability to respond to changing sea levels. As coral atoll islands, the accumulation of coral debris as well as the trapping of sediment by the atolls explains how they are able to grow, because they are made of once-living material that is continuously being added by new growth. The growth of atolls was first explained by Charles Darwin in The Voyage of the Beagle
Because the mechanism of growth and stabilization is specific to this type of island, though, it means that other kinds of landmass, such as sandbar islands, are still susceptible to inundation by rising sea levels. This report does not mean that we have nothing to worry from climate change, though it must come as a partial relief to inhabitants of atoll island nations in the Pacific.
------
New Scientist magazine has a feature on the research that was erroneously cited by The Australian newspaper as the source where the study was published (their headline: "Pacific islands have not shrunk: New Scientist study").
This is an annoying characteristic of newspaper science journalism, that articles often mis-cite or do not cite the original sources where the research was published. It's frustrating for readers who want to find out more, or to verify for themselves the claims made in the newspaper articles (which may be sensationalized by journalists or subeditors looking for a catchy headline). It's shoddy journalism, too, because the sources were not carefully scrutinized before being written up, though in The Australian's writer's defence, perhaps he didn't know how scientific publishing works.
It's getting better in some places, though. BBC News now names the journals in which research which it features are published, although they still don't cite the year or volume, or state whether the write-up is based on work that's still in press.
Let's hope for more awareness of proper citation; otherwise the so-called 'news' might degenerate into a game of Chinese Whispers.
Land area change was small compared to other 'gross changes':
"...changes in the planform configuration and position of islands on reef platforms. Modes of island change included: ocean shoreline displacement toward the lagoon; lagoon shoreline progradation; and, extension of the ends of elongate islands."
The composition of the islands is responsible for their dynamism and ability to respond to changing sea levels. As coral atoll islands, the accumulation of coral debris as well as the trapping of sediment by the atolls explains how they are able to grow, because they are made of once-living material that is continuously being added by new growth. The growth of atolls was first explained by Charles Darwin in The Voyage of the Beagle
Because the mechanism of growth and stabilization is specific to this type of island, though, it means that other kinds of landmass, such as sandbar islands, are still susceptible to inundation by rising sea levels. This report does not mean that we have nothing to worry from climate change, though it must come as a partial relief to inhabitants of atoll island nations in the Pacific.
------
New Scientist magazine has a feature on the research that was erroneously cited by The Australian newspaper as the source where the study was published (their headline: "Pacific islands have not shrunk: New Scientist study").
This is an annoying characteristic of newspaper science journalism, that articles often mis-cite or do not cite the original sources where the research was published. It's frustrating for readers who want to find out more, or to verify for themselves the claims made in the newspaper articles (which may be sensationalized by journalists or subeditors looking for a catchy headline). It's shoddy journalism, too, because the sources were not carefully scrutinized before being written up, though in The Australian's writer's defence, perhaps he didn't know how scientific publishing works.
It's getting better in some places, though. BBC News now names the journals in which research which it features are published, although they still don't cite the year or volume, or state whether the write-up is based on work that's still in press.
Let's hope for more awareness of proper citation; otherwise the so-called 'news' might degenerate into a game of Chinese Whispers.
Harold Varmus on Open Access Publishing
Harold Varmus, former NIH director and instigator of open-access publishing, writes a personal account (PDF file) of his conversion to open-access, and the events leading to the founding of PubMed Central and Public Library of Science (PLoS).
The paper was originally presented at a symposium in 2007 organized by the American Philosophical Society.
He rightfully points out the basic facts behind this issue: most scientific research is paid for by public funds, and scientists themselves contribute their time and energy to peer-review and edit articles for scientific journals as part of their service to the scientific community (and to build up their own resumes).
However, for-profit companies (and some non-profit societies) that publish these journals charge subscribers high rates (often several thousands a year for institutional subscriptions) and enjoy large profit margins. In an (probably) unintended confluence with other current events, he quotes a report from the now-defunct investment firm Bear Stearns that calls the European publishing conglomerate Reed-Elsevier "a stockholder's dream come true."
Being then the director of the NIH, which funds most biomedical research in the US, he came to the realization that his agency was inadvertently subsidizing the publishing industry to the tune of perhaps 1 billion dollars a year.
One may or may not agree with the PLoS model of open-access, where authors of scientific articles have to cough up publication fees (of a few thousand dollars) to make their work freely available to the public. His essay is however still good reading for anyone interested in a spirited insider's look into the politics and economics of science.
The paper was originally presented at a symposium in 2007 organized by the American Philosophical Society.
He rightfully points out the basic facts behind this issue: most scientific research is paid for by public funds, and scientists themselves contribute their time and energy to peer-review and edit articles for scientific journals as part of their service to the scientific community (and to build up their own resumes).
However, for-profit companies (and some non-profit societies) that publish these journals charge subscribers high rates (often several thousands a year for institutional subscriptions) and enjoy large profit margins. In an (probably) unintended confluence with other current events, he quotes a report from the now-defunct investment firm Bear Stearns that calls the European publishing conglomerate Reed-Elsevier "a stockholder's dream come true."
Being then the director of the NIH, which funds most biomedical research in the US, he came to the realization that his agency was inadvertently subsidizing the publishing industry to the tune of perhaps 1 billion dollars a year.
One may or may not agree with the PLoS model of open-access, where authors of scientific articles have to cough up publication fees (of a few thousand dollars) to make their work freely available to the public. His essay is however still good reading for anyone interested in a spirited insider's look into the politics and economics of science.
Thursday, May 20, 2010
NY Times New Field Scientist Blog

Science! As it happens! The New York Times website has a new blog, called Scientist at Work, the aim of which is, as they put it, "to give scientists in the field a chance to describe what they do as they are doing it."
Of course most day-to-day science is abysmally boring. It's interesting to think about science and talk about it, but to actually watch someone carry out a hundred PCR reactions or measure the second tarsi of countless pinned beetles for an afternoon is... not very entertaining. So trust the field biologists to jump at the chance to portray themselves as modern-day explorers, as the ones who truly get to see the action. Lots of breathtaking photographs too, such as this latest entry on Philippine nudibranchs written by Terry Gosliner of the California Academy of Sciences.
Don't expect to see too much ink spilled about the months of permit-haggling, visa-stamping, and grant-writing that bracket any field expedition, though. And why should there be, anyway? It doesn't interest the public, and those who would know about the boring bits don't need to be reminded. Even seasoned scientists and naturalists need to take a step back from the minutiae, every now and then, and reaffirm that what they study is truly exciting and awesome.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Evolve Music!
What happens when you cross modern European musical tastes with biological geekiness? A project like Darwin Rocks! This online game was produced by the Animal Evolutionary Ecology group at Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen. It generates a few short pieces of synthetic music that has a number of variable traits: type of beat, instruments, key, rhythm. The user selects which ones he or she likes and dislikes, and then 'evolves' them for a number of generations. Repeat this process, and eventually, or so the idea is, you get a piece of music that has evolved to fit your musical preferences!
A neat way to spend a lazy afternoon, but one drawback is that most casual browsers will not attentively listen to all of the clips in their entirety. The 'hidden variation' that you don't observe can actually make the results quite different from what you were expecting! At least when I tried it out, it was producing some pretty awful sounds....
But it's worth visiting to have a look at the promotional music video they've made to illustrate the principle of Darwinian fitness. Or as the press release says: "The song and the music video with the title “Struggle for love” are about love, fight, and the right mix in evolution."
Sunday, April 18, 2010
Phylo - trading card game for real organisms
Spurred by the success of trading card games like Pokemon, biologist David Ng at the University of British Columbia has created a card game called Phylo (also called 'Phylomon' by some), and is soliciting original artwork to build up the deck. The project is consciously tapping into the crowdsourcing and social media phenomena to find volunteers to create content, and it appears to be a great opportunity for the artistically-inclined to contribute. The cards themselves can be downloaded and printed from the website. The site suggests a number of games that can be played, ranging from 'ecological interaction' games to simpler-minded 'X beats Y' games, but as the FAQ notes it's not really meaningful to pit a blue whale against an oak tree and decide which of the two should 'win'.

The inspiration for this project was a 2002 letter in Science entitled "Why Conservationists Should Heed Pokemon". In that letter, a group of Cambridge biologists describe a survey of schoolchildren they carried out, handing them pictures of common Pokemon and common British wildlife. They found that the ability to identify wildlife increased moderately with age, but the ability to identify Pokemon rose much faster and in older children exceeded their wildlife recognition skills.
I suppose the biggest problem facing all projects like this is to make it fun without seeming cheesy. Crowd sourcing seems like a promising way to tap into a large talent pool, though uniformity of the artwork and presentation may be lost in the process.
Also, to make a plug for my old lab, there's a similar but more structured card game featuring insects and invertebrates of the Boston Harbor Islands, called PredatOR Prey where the player matches up predators with their potential prey.
(via Hann, Siva, and others)

The inspiration for this project was a 2002 letter in Science entitled "Why Conservationists Should Heed Pokemon". In that letter, a group of Cambridge biologists describe a survey of schoolchildren they carried out, handing them pictures of common Pokemon and common British wildlife. They found that the ability to identify wildlife increased moderately with age, but the ability to identify Pokemon rose much faster and in older children exceeded their wildlife recognition skills.
I suppose the biggest problem facing all projects like this is to make it fun without seeming cheesy. Crowd sourcing seems like a promising way to tap into a large talent pool, though uniformity of the artwork and presentation may be lost in the process.
Also, to make a plug for my old lab, there's a similar but more structured card game featuring insects and invertebrates of the Boston Harbor Islands, called PredatOR Prey where the player matches up predators with their potential prey.
(via Hann, Siva, and others)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)