Saturday, January 26, 2013

Taxonomists are not going extinct

When talking to people studying biodiversity, one often hears that "taxonomists are a dying breed", an opinion that has been expressed on this blog before.

A newly-published meta-analysis looks at whether science can realistically finish cataloging all the world's biological species before they go extinct:
"Some people despair that most species will go extinct before they are discovered. However, such worries result from overestimates of how many species may exist, beliefs that the expertise to describe species is decreasing, and alarmist estimates of extinction rates. We argue that the number of species on Earth today is 5 ± 3 million, of which 1.5 million are named. New databases show that there are more taxonomists describing species than ever before, and their number is increasing faster than the rate of species description. Conservation efforts and species survival in secondary habitats are at least delaying extinctions. Extinction rates are, however, poorly quantified, ranging from 0.01 to 1% (at most 5%) per decade. We propose practical actions to improve taxonomic productivity and associated understanding and conservation of biodiversity."
They found that it's not true that taxonomists are a dying breed, but that the profession is undergoing a geographical shift from Western countries where modern taxonomy and big museum collections were first developed, to South America and Asia-Pacific countries. They argue that this is a good development because those are the countries where much of the world's biodiversity actually lies.

The number of active taxonomists was estimated by looking at databases to find out who is publishing new species descriptions. It's also not true that the current generation of taxonomists are mostly "one-hit wonders" who only describe one or two new species in their careers; there is not much difference between the previous and current generations of taxonomists in their productivity.

If we want to catalog all the world's biodiversity, declining lack of expertise is then not the problem. What's problematic is that even as we are still in a state of ignorance about the world's biodiversity, species are going extinct at a steady rate due to human activity. We are also victims of our own success: as more and more species have been described, it becomes harder to find new ones among the existing known diversity. It's like being stuck at home for the weekend: after you've read most of the books and watched most of the movies in your house, it's harder to find something new to do (at least before the Internet...).

But what's the point of all this taxonomic toil? Why describe new species? The questions of "how many species on Earth?" and "what is the extinction rate?" are notoriously difficult to answer. Whereas we now have a fair guess at the answer to the first question, estimates of the extinction rate vary widely, reflecting the huge uncertainties involved. As the authors point out: "Taxonomists are not in danger of extinction. They are increasing in numbers and will become more in demand as more species mean more diagnostic challenges to discriminate species, whether they are pests, pathogens, food, ecological keystone, or endangered species." This highlights how knowledge of biodiversity is important, both for its own sake and for the sake of human interests.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Keystone species, Keystone teacher?

Keystone species are members of ecological communities that have a disproportionate effect on the community if they are removed. They need not be the most abundant element, but may play an important role, e.g. in keeping down the population of some other species that would otherwise dominate.

The classic experiment was performed in the 1960s by ecologist Bob Paine, who removed a species of sea star Pisaster ochraeus from a rocky shore intertidal environment. In months, the community became dominated by mussels and decreased in diversity. Because of this, he coined the term "keystone species" for the role that this sea star was playing in this community.

Pisaster ochraeus (via Wikimedia)
Paine himself has had a disproportionate influence on the academic community in the field of ecology. This profile article describes his career and students, and illustrates well how a single teacher can not only be a good mentor to his or her students, but also go beyond that to build a scientific family.

Saturday, January 05, 2013

Carl Woese, Discoverer of the Archaea, RIP

One of the first things that students learn today about the diversity of life is the concept of the Three Domains of Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya. In the past, they would have learned about the Five Kingdoms — Prokaryotes, Animals, Plants, Fungi, and Protists —a concept popularized by the late Lynn Margulis, but we now know that the animals, plants, and fungi are relative newcomers on the evolutionary scene, and that the "prokaryotes" actually contain two ancient lineages, the Bacteria and Archaea, which split long before the eukaryotic kingdoms.

Carl Woese in 2006, via U Illinois


For this insight, we can thank Carl Woese, who passed away just before the New Year at the age of 84 (U Illinois press release, NY Times obituary). Woese made his discovery in the 1970s, when sequencing DNA and RNA was anything but routine. At that time, the prokaryotes were classified primarily by physiological characteristics and morphological appearance. There was little attention paid to microbial evolution, except in a speculative way, simply because there was no easy way to go about studying it.

Wallace's biogeographic map updated - and there are three new realms

Three new realms have been added to an update of Wallace's biogeographic map: Panamia, Sino-Japanese and Oecania. The abstract says, "a global map of zoogeographic regions was generated by combining data on the distributions and phylogenetic relationships of 21,037 species of amphibians, birds, and mammals. 20 distinct zoogeographic regions are grouped into 11 larger realms.

Phylogenetic information provides valuable insight on historical relationships among regions, permitting the identification of evolutionarily unique regions of the world."

11 realms in new biogeographical map
“Wallace’s map still makes a lot of sense,” said Jean-Philippe Lessard, an ecologist at McGill University in Montreal who was formerly at the University of Copenhagen. “We’re not inventing anything here, we’re just implementing Wallace’s vision at an age where we have tons of DNA and more information on where species are on the planet.”
- see the article in New York Times. Article: Holt et al., 2012. An update of Wallace’s zoogeographic regions of the world. Science, 339 (6115): 74-78. DOI: 10.1126/science.1228282. Published online 20 Dec 2012.

Google Earth resource available from: http://macroecology.ku.dk/resources/wallace.

Thanks to Leong Wai for the alert.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Children of the wilderness


A young girl disappears in the forest while playing with a cousin. The cousin is found several days later, but no one can find the girl. Some time later, stories emerge from the forest about a girl seen walking alongside a tiger, about a wild woman walking around with long hair and nails, but she is never found and the search is eventually abandoned. Thirty-eight years later, she is finally rediscovered at the age of 42, after having wandered through the forests on the borders of three different countries. 

This sounds like a chapter from a magical realist novel, or some fairy-tale fable, but it is the true story of Ng Chhaidy from the district of Mizoram in India, close to the border with Myanmar. Chhaidy’s story is astonishing for the length of time that she has been missing, long enough for her to lose the ability to use language, even though she was fluent in her native Mara when she disappeared as a four-year-old. It seems remarkable to those of us living in the developed and urbanized world, far removed from close contact with forest and wilderness, that such a thing could happen in modern times. 

Monday, September 10, 2012

Giving “junk DNA” the credit that it’s due



When the Human Genome Project was completed over a decade ago, in 2001, many biologists were surprised that the human genome only contains about 20000 to 25000 genes, which occupy less than 1% of the total DNA sequence. This was surprising news: how could such a complex system as a human being be coded for by only 25000 instructions, when a microscopic worm (C. elegans) has 21000, and a bacterium (E. coli) has 5000? And what was the point of carrying all this other DNA around? The term “junk DNA” was coined to refer to these non-protein-coding sequences. Are they really junk — relics of past evolution, gene duplication, viral infection, and other hypothesized mechanisms of sequence accumulation — or do they have a function that we simply haven’t found out about yet?

The ENCODE (Encyclopedia of DNA Elements) project has recently released its first results in a series of publications in Nature and other scientific journals. There was plenty of news surrounding it; not surprising given the $180 million that have already been spent, and the over 400 scientists working on it. Articles appeared in major newspapers and news outlets, but then I got an email from a college friend, who’s not a biologist, asking me what all this fuss was about. He’d read the newspaper articles, which were full of quotes from scientists lavishing praise on the project and its promise, but couldn’t quite figure out exactly what it was about. The generic-sounding name of the project doesn’t give many clues, either. And so, even though I’m supposed to be a microbiologist and not a human geneticist, I thought I’d take a shot at explaining the significance of the ENCODE results.

The idea of the “gene” has been a long and problematic one. It has a peculiar history for a biological concept, because the existence of genes was predicted by theory (the experiments of Mendel and his successors) long before we had any clue of what the physical nature of genes were. Eventually biologists figured out that DNA was the hereditary material, and the Central Dogma took shape: that genetic information stored on DNA was first transcribed to RNA, which was then translated to proteins, and that proteins were the main functioning parts of the cell: the scaffolding, motors, and carriers that performed the business of life. A gene was just the information needed to make a protein, and if asked to define the physical manifestation of a gene, one would have said that it was the stretch of DNA that held the instructions for making that protein.

As we found out more about genes and how they were regulated, however, the story began to get complicated. It wasn’t necessarily true that one gene = one protein: some genes could be spliced in different ways to give different products. Nor was it true that proteins were the only functional pieces of the cell: sure, we’ve known about ribosomal RNAs (rRNA) and transfer RNAs (tRNA) for a long time, but other small RNAs, some with catalytic functions, have also been discovered. Gradually, we’ve also come to appreciate that the complexity of life is not just the result of proteins interacting with other proteins, with DNA sitting passively by; many proteins also interact with DNA, determining which genes are going to be expressed, and which should stay silent. In the classical textbook examples, regulatory elements lie close to the genes which they administer, but it is now known that this isn’t necessarily so. New mechanisms of silencing genes have been discovered, some which work by chemically modifying DNA (methylation), and others which involve a dizzying dance of RNA and protein molecules (RNA interference). Is it time to revise the concept of the “gene”, or should we simply acknowledge that protein-coding genes are not the only significant pieces of a genome?

The ENCODE project has shown this very clearly. Far from being “junk”, the non-protein-coding sequences in a genome are actually doing something and not just sitting there passively. At least 80% of the genome can be experimentally shown to have some kind of function (recall that less than 1% of the genome codes for proteins), or as the authors put it: a “demonstrable biochemical function”. They may be regulators or promoters, i.e. sequences which control the expression of genes by binding to proteins involved in the machinery of transcription. They could be regions that are controlled by DNA methylation, which silences expression. Or they could be regions which are exposed to transcription factors, instead of being coiled up in histones.

This was a large scale project with many participants. What they did to discover this was a process of systematic cataloging. They used almost 150 different human cell lines in culture (including the famous HeLa cells) and performed different experiments to spot different functions. For example, to see what portion of the DNA was actually being transcribed, they extracted and sequenced RNA en masse, an approach made possible by new methods of nucleic acid sequencing which can sequence huge numbers of small lengths very quickly. To see what sequences bind to known proteins, they performed a method called ChIP, chromatin immunoprecipitation. For a protein which is thought to bind to DNA, antibodies are raised against it. The protein is then exposed to genomic DNA; it seeks out and binds to the specific sequence that it interacts with. A chemical is added to cross-link the protein and DNA, and this complex is fished out using the antibodies developed earlier. The crosslinks are removed, and the DNA is sequenced, to find out what region of the genome this protein interacts with. Other types of experiments were performed to find out which parts of the genome are methylated, are accessible to transcription factors, and so on. They’ve also analyzed how the regulatory elements in a genome interact with each other, and how the three-dimensional folding of the DNA itself affects the interactions between different parts of the genome.

One of the surprising findings was that much of the genome (75%) is actually transcribed to RNA at some point or another, even though most of these don’t end up being translated to proteins. Textbooks usually mention the three classical types of RNA: messenger RNA (mRNA), rRNA, and tRNA (described above), but aside from these workhorses, RNA was usually thought of as a sort of “relic” molecule, doing only these few menial jobs. But recent research is accumulating evidence for the importance of various kinds of small RNAs in the eukaryotic cell, and the ENCODE project could help the task of cataloging them all. 

There are a whole bunch of other sub-projects (or “threads”, as they call them on the ENCODE website) that have been carried out by the ENCODE consortium. As a way of doing science, I think it points the way to the future: big consortia collecting big data and crunching big numbers. For biology, the new sequencing technologies (collectively called “next-generation sequencing”, or NGS) are a tremendous advance over traditional Sanger-type sequencing, which was developed decades ago and still based on the same principles. NGS came into the market just in time for the ENCODE project, allowing them to sequence several times as much DNA for the same cost. We are now reaching the point when you could have your own personal genome sequence for a thousand dollars or even less. The limit on what we can do is imposed instead by our ability to store, transmit, and compute such massive quantities of data. 

---

The first batch of papers published by the ENCODE consortium are available via the website of Nature. They’ve also got some snazzy interactive graphics. 

Monday, August 20, 2012

Stephen Asma on Body Worlds and the macabre

Humans have always been fascinated by death and the macabre. Long before Body Worlds brought plastinated human bodies on display around the world, people were jostling to see mummies dug out of dusty crypts, or executed murderers freshly cut down from the gallows. Stephen Asma, whose interest in death, decay, and decrepitude has been marked by books on monsters (On Monsters) and natural history museums (Stuffed Animals and Pickled Heads), writes about our shared predilection to gawp at death. I cannot deny being one of the gawpers myself, either!

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Google Earth and Science

Google Earth and its cousin, Google Maps, are really useful. I don't think I've used a street directory or road map since I learned how convenient it was to just google it. Aside from just being a tool for finding out how to get from point A to point B, or for businesses to promote themselves, it's also a great tool for crowdsourcing, as memorably happened after the Haiti earthquake two years ago.

It's really useful for scientists too. I'm sure many of us have used Google Maps to check out field sites before going there, and also afterwards to plot localities and routes. The terms "virtual globe" or "Digital Earth" refers generally to such tools, which represent geographical features in digital form. A recent paper in PNAS looks at how current virtual globe tools have been used to help science and make it accessible to the public, and what the prospects are for the future.

One way to get more out of Google Maps is to use KML, a standard markup language for displaying geographical data in virtual globe software (tutorial). If you already use the "My Maps" feature, you can download your maps as KML to share with others. Alternatively, if you want to plot known coordinates and annotate them, you can mark up your data as KML and import into Google Earth to visualize it. 

Sunday, May 20, 2012

Scientific turnover and the fate of old theory


The Arts and Sciences are often seen as non-overlapping complements, as naturally opposed as North and South, or the two sexes male and female. It's therefore surprising to find someone who can make a significant career in both, not just as an amateur but as a paid professional.

Vladimir Nabokov is best known as the author of the novel Lolita, but before becoming famous for his writing in English, he was a professional lepidopterist, an expert on a group of butterflies known as the Blues. An earlier blog post here highlighted some recent research on "his" group of butterflies.

His two careers were also the subject of an essay by Stephen Jay Gould. Gould used Nabokov's example to examine our attitudes to "genius". If Nabokov was a genius in literature, does it follow that his scientific work was also illuminated by the same genius? Was his scientific writing especially fluent or literary, as some literary critics claim? Gould found that, in the opinion of other professional lepidopterists, Nabokov's scientific work was competent and painstaking, but not especially pathbreaking or profound. Nor was his scientific writing unusually poetic or stylistically striking, in the way that his novels were.

In fact, Gould goes as far as to characterize Nabokov as being somewhat of a "stick in the mud." At the time when he was engaged in his butterfly work full-time at the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard, from 1942 to 1948, a revolution was underway in taxonomy. Where previously the morphological characters, such as wing coloration or genital anatomy (a serious preoccupation of much of entomology!) were the means by which new species were defined, the budding science of cytology (the study of cells) had introduced chromosomes as yet another important character. "Cryptic" species with identical morphology were now being defined on the basis of their differing karyotypes (the number and appearance of the chromosomes). Nabokov rejected the use of chromosomes for defining new species, perhaps as a matter of practicality: pinned butterfly specimens in museums only preserve the morphology, so it would be impossible to distinguish karyotype variants in the museum cabinet.

His autobiography, however, seems to belie this depiction of Nabokov as a rigid conservative. Nabokov spoke about "great upheavals... taking place in the development of systematics." The year that Nabokov started working in the Museum was also the year that Ernst Mayr, by then also an emigre to the United States, published his Systematics and the Origin of Species, the book which established the biological species concept, that species (at least for sexual macroorganisms like birds and insects) are defined by their potential for breeding to produce viable offspring. The new emerging school of taxonomy represented by Mayr were strong champions of geographic variation. Species were not immutable, platonic ideals. The variation represented by geographic "races" or subspecies was just as important as the original "type" of a species. Conceptually, this so-called Neo-Darwinian revolution was when darwinism finally became orthodoxy in taxonomy, the field that had inspired it, nearly a century after the publication of the Origin of Species.

Nabokov was aware of this theoretical revolution - how could he have ignored it? This was a tremendous change from the lepidoptery of his youth, which could well be said to be truly "butterfly collecting". As he observed:
"Since the middle of the [19th] century, Continental lepidopterology had been, on the whole, a simple and stable affair, smoothly run by the Germans. Its high priest, Dr. Staudinger, was also the head of the largest firm of insect dealers. Even now, half a century after his death, German lepidopterists have not quite managed to shake off the hypnotic spell occasioned by his authority. He was still alive when his school began to lose ground as a scientific force in the world. While he and his followers stuck to specific and generic names sanctioned by long usage and were content to classify butterflies by characters visible to the naked eye, English-speaking authors were introducing nomenclaturial changes as a result of a strict application of the law of priority and taxonomic changes based on the microscopic study of organs. The Germans did their best to ignore the new trends and continued to cherish the philately-like side of entomology. Their solicitude for the "average collector who should not be made to dissect" is comparable to the way nervous publishers of popular novels pamper the "average reader"--who should not be made to think. 
"There was another more general change, which coincided with my ardent adolescent interest in butterflies and moths. The Victorian and Staudingerian kind of species, hermetic and homogeneous, with sundry (alpine, polar, insular, etc.) "varieties" affixed to it from the outside, as it were, like incidental appendages, was replaced by a new multiform and fluid kind of species, organically consisting of geographical races or subspecies. The evolutionary aspects of the case were thus brought out more clearly, by means of more flexible methods of classification, and further links between butterflies and the central problems of nature were provided by biological investigations."  
(Speak, Memory: An Autobiography Revisited, pp.122-123)
So it wasn't that Nabokov was a conservative who didn't like change. He had already spanned the era between "hobbyist" and scientific entomology. He was already witness to a revolution (in science, and also in his homeland of Russia). There's a quip I've heard attributed to the physicist Max Planck, that science doesn't progress because people come to accept new theories on the strength of their evidence; it progresses because old scientists who believe the old theories die out. It's certainly an exaggeration, but we are equally certainly products of our education. Every generation in science has its own revolution of understanding, and maybe it's unfair to expect someone to accommodate a second one, just as he or she was getting comfortable with the first!

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

How to foster good science in Singapore?

The institute in Germany where I'm studying was recently subject to an external review. Our staff and students got to mingle with the reviewers at a dinner in-house one evening, and while waiting in line at the buffet I started talking to someone who turned out to be a senior official in our research organization and also a practicing biologist.

I mentioned that I was from Singapore, and there was a look of recognition in his face. He asked me "ah, A-Star?" Like many others around the world who work in science, he knew about Singapore's big investment in research and technology, and of course also knew about Philip Yeo ("a very smart man"). But he also felt that the Singapore model had a few serious shortcomings, and after our conversation I thought it would be useful to share some of these observations, especially because they are held by someone who is himself a senior scientist and is responsible for administering a large scientific organization.

Singapore has been very successful at setting up the physical infrastructure for research, mobilizing plenty of money and political will to build new institutes and stock them with equipment and supplies. In terms of talent, which is the perennial Singaporean question, we've gone for a top-down approach: recruiting the "big names" in various fields, giving them very good salaries (the few scientists in the US whom I've talked about this before have all mentioned the attractive remuneration) and more importantly the funding to continue their projects in Singapore.

The official said that he didn't think this was the best way to build up a scientific community. What about the students? As he put it, if you're a senior scientist wanting to set up a lab in another institution, the first question you're going to ask is whether you're going to have good students (who of course do all the actual lab work). Unfortunately, Singapore seems to do a very good job of exporting its best students. They're sent overseas on fully-funded, prestigious scholarships to foreign institutions. In the case of A-Star's PhD scholarships, the recipients only make their way back to Singapore after about a decade of study abroad, and maybe even longer if they do a post-doctoral fellowship or two to gain additional experience. While they are overseas, they're not just learning but actively contributing to science. I think that most graduate students would agree that graduate school is not about learning at the feet of your professors, but is instead about finding one's own way in science, while being guided to independence. As a research student, you are actively making science while learning it.

My own experiences appear to bear this out. When I was studying in the US, it was (and is) common for undergrads to do active scientific research, usually mentored by graduate students or post-docs; this was something that was actively encouraged. When asked about undergraduate research opportunities, many professors would comment on how fortunate they themselves were to be in an institution where bright and motivated young people would come and ask to work with them. The professors are undoubtedly good at what they do, but they need good students to keep the research going at a high level, and they recognize this fact.

I explained to him that such scholarships are not limited to the sciences, but are also the most culturally prestigious means for recruitment to careers in public service. At that point I saw the general relevance of what he had said to this entire system of talent recruitment. It's not just about the money that's being spent on having these students shipped abroad and tutored far away from home. Prestige matters too. If the best students do not stay in the country, then it is difficult to develop local institutions to higher levels. Worse still, we are not building confidence in our own institutions.

The foregoing isn't meant to say that the research and graduate students in Singapore are not up to par. Several of my friends are doing science in Singapore, and they certainly have motivation and ability. The matter is whether, for the amount of resources we have poured into the project, we can build up a human infrastructure to match the physical infrastructure.

It's not about how many citations or high-impact papers we can garner. It's about whether we can build a self-sustaining research community that will renew itself by training new scientists. Instead of importing "big names" (the top-down model), let's find a better way to nurture the talent we already have (the bottom-up model).



Some other comments:

I myself am a participant in the (I hope, temporary) brain-drain, although I'm not on a state-funded scholarship. As I want to return home to work in Singapore in the future, I feel that I have to keep an eye on how science and research are developing there. I've also decided not to name the official that I talked to because I don't want it to seem like these are the official views of our organization, neither did I think at the time to ask him for his permission to share them publicly.

Also, the model for scientific training that I've described -- senior scientists leading labs training graduate students who also generate the scientific results and publications -- is causing serious problems in other developed countries, especially the US. Supply of newly-minted PhDs seriously outstrips demand, in terms of the number of new faculty positions opening up for them in academia. This is a well-recognized problem (see the careers pages of many recent issues of Nature and Science), and according to this perspective article in Science, the seeds for the current situation were sown in the 1940s with the recommendations of Vannevar Bush that led to the establishment of the National Science Foundation in the US. That's another unpleasant outcome that we have to avoid.